RankProduct NameScore
1Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box - GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer CoverGraco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress in a Box – GREENGUARD Gold Certified, Non-Toxic, Breathable, Removable Washable Water Resistant Outer Cover
Storkcraft
9.9GET ON AMAZON
2Milliard Crib Mattress, Flip Technology, Firm Side for Baby and Soft Side for Toddler, Hypoallergenic - 100% Cotton CoverMilliard Crib Mattress, Flip Technology, Firm Side for Baby and Soft Side for Toddler, Hypoallergenic – 100% Cotton Cover
Milliard
9.6GET ON AMAZON
3Sealy Baby Firm Rest Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress - 204 Premium Coils, Luxury Design Pattern May Vary, 51.7" x 27.3"Sealy Baby Firm Rest Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress – 204 Premium Coils, Luxury Design Pattern May Vary, 51.7″ x 27.3″
Kolcraft
9.4GET ON AMAZON
4Sealy Baby Perfect Rest Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress - 150 Extra Firm Coils, 51.7" x 27.3"Sealy Baby Perfect Rest Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress – 150 Extra Firm Coils, 51.7″ x 27.3″
Kolcraft
9.3GET ON AMAZON
5hiccapop Baby Crib Mattress [Dual Sided] w/Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) | Memory Foam Crib Mattress | Toddler Bed Mattress | Baby Mattress for Cribhiccapop Baby Crib Mattress [Dual Sided] w/Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) | Memory Foam Crib Mattress | Toddler Bed Mattress | Baby Mattress for Crib
hiccapop
9.2GET ON AMAZON
6Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress | Waterproof | GREENGUARD Gold Certified (Natural/Non-Toxic)Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress | Waterproof | GREENGUARD Gold Certified (Natural/Non-Toxic)
Children’s Products LLC.
9.1GET ON AMAZON
7Sealy Baby Posturepedic Crown Jewel Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress - 220 PostureTech Sensory Coils, 51.7" x 27.3"Sealy Baby Posturepedic Crown Jewel Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress – 220 PostureTech Sensory Coils, 51.7″ x 27.3″
Kolcraft
8.9GET ON AMAZON
8Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress - Lightweight Crib Mattress with Extra Firm Infant Side and Plush Toddler SideMoonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress – Lightweight Crib Mattress with Extra Firm Infant Side and Plush Toddler Side
Moonlight Slumber
8.9GET ON AMAZON
9hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad [Dual Sided] w/Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) | Memory Foam Play Yard Mattress Pad | Playard Mattress Fits Most Pack N Play Playpenshiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad [Dual Sided] w/Firm Side (for Babies) & Soft Memory Foam Side (for Toddlers) | Memory Foam Play Yard Mattress Pad | Playard Mattress Fits Most Pack N Play Playpens
hiccapop
8.7GET ON AMAZON
10Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Crib Mattress | Eco-Friendly Foam | Organic Waterproof Cotton Cover | GREENGUARD Gold Certified| HypoallergenicColgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Crib Mattress | Eco-Friendly Foam | Organic Waterproof Cotton Cover | GREENGUARD Gold Certified| Hypoallergenic
Colgate
8.5GET ON AMAZON