RankProduct NameScore
11998 Topps Football #360 Peyton Manning Rookie Card1998 Topps Football #360 Peyton Manning Rookie Card
Topps
9.9GET ON AMAZON
21998 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Score NFL Football Mint Rookie Card in Protective Display Case1998 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Score NFL Football Mint Rookie Card in Protective Display Case
9.8GET ON AMAZON
31998 Bowman Football #1 Peyton Manning Rookie Card1998 Bowman Football #1 Peyton Manning Rookie Card
Topps
9.7GET ON AMAZON
42006 Score NFL Football MASSIVE Factory Sealed Complete Factory Set with 440 Cards! Includes 110 ROOKIE Cards Plus NFL Hall of Famers Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Brett Favre & More! $50 Value! WOWZZER!2006 Score NFL Football MASSIVE Factory Sealed Complete Factory Set with 440 Cards! Includes 110 ROOKIE Cards Plus NFL Hall of Famers Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Brett Favre & More! $50 Value! WOWZZER!
Wowzzer
9.6GET ON AMAZON
51998 Topps Football Series Factory Sealed Set Which Includes Rookie Cards of Peyton Manning and Randy Moss Plus Stars Including Jerry Rice, Brett Favre, John Elway, Dan Marino, Troy Aikman, Barry Sanders, Joe Montana and Many Others.1998 Topps Football Series Factory Sealed Set Which Includes Rookie Cards of Peyton Manning and Randy Moss Plus Stars Including Jerry Rice, Brett Favre, John Elway, Dan Marino, Troy Aikman, Barry Sanders, Joe Montana and Many Others.
Topps
9.5GET ON AMAZON
62011 Topps Rising Rookies Football Card # 20 Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts - NFL Trading Card Protective Screwdown Display Case2011 Topps Rising Rookies Football Card # 20 Peyton Manning – Indianapolis Colts – NFL Trading Card Protective Screwdown Display Case
Topps
9.4GET ON AMAZON
7Denver Broncos 2018 Donruss Factory Sealed NFL Football Complete Mint 15 Card Team Set with John Elway, Von Miller, Rookie cards of Bradley Chubb, Courtland Sutton and othersDenver Broncos 2018 Donruss Factory Sealed NFL Football Complete Mint 15 Card Team Set with John Elway, Von Miller, Rookie cards of Bradley Chubb, Courtland Sutton and others
Donruss
9.0GET ON AMAZON
8AARON RODGERS/TOM BRADY/PEYTON MANNING/BRETT FAVRE SIGNATURED GEMMT10 23KT GOLD RETRO DRAFT ROOKIE CARD LOT!AARON RODGERS/TOM BRADY/PEYTON MANNING/BRETT FAVRE SIGNATURED GEMMT10 23KT GOLD RETRO DRAFT ROOKIE CARD LOT!
Merrick Mint
8.8GET ON AMAZON
9PEYTON MANNING 1998 Draft Pick FEEL THE GAME Gold Card - Graded GEM MINT 10PEYTON MANNING 1998 Draft Pick FEEL THE GAME Gold Card – Graded GEM MINT 10
Merrick Mint
8.5GET ON AMAZON
10Denver Broncos 3 Team Set Factory Sealed Gift Lot Including 2015, 2013 and 2011 Score Broncos Sets Featuring 2 Different Peyton Manning Cards Plus Rookies and MoreDenver Broncos 3 Team Set Factory Sealed Gift Lot Including 2015, 2013 and 2011 Score Broncos Sets Featuring 2 Different Peyton Manning Cards Plus Rookies and More
Score
8.2GET ON AMAZON