RankProduct NameScore
1Baby Keepsake Box - First MotherBaby Keepsake Box – First Mother’s Day Gift Newborn Keepsake Gift – Pregnancy Gift – Baby Shower Gift – Memory Box Personalized Handmade, Acid-Free, Built to Last + Memento Organizer – Slate
Savor
9.8GET ON AMAZON
2Luna Bean Infant Plaster Statue Casting Keepsake Kit - Cast Baby Hand & Foot (0-9M) (Clear Glaze)Luna Bean Infant Plaster Statue Casting Keepsake Kit – Cast Baby Hand & Foot (0-9M) (Clear Glaze)
Casting Keepsakes
9.6GET ON AMAZON
3Pearhead Babyprints Newborn Baby Handprint and Footprint Photo Frame Kit and Included Safe For Baby Clean-Touch Ink Pad, WhitePearhead Babyprints Newborn Baby Handprint and Footprint Photo Frame Kit and Included Safe For Baby Clean-Touch Ink Pad, White
Pearhead
9.4GET ON AMAZON
4Baby Memory Book with Keepsake Box and  30 Monthly Baby First Milestone Stickers - Gender Neutral First Year Scrapbook Journal - Baby Photo Album for Boys and GirlsBaby Memory Book with Keepsake Box and 30 Monthly Baby First Milestone Stickers – Gender Neutral First Year Scrapbook Journal – Baby Photo Album for Boys and Girls
Next Mommy
9.2GET ON AMAZON
5Pearhead Babyprints Newborn Baby Print Baby Handprint and Footprint Photo Frame Kit, No Bake Clay Keepsake, Newborn Baby Registry Must Haves, Baby Shower Gift, WhitePearhead Babyprints Newborn Baby Print Baby Handprint and Footprint Photo Frame Kit, No Bake Clay Keepsake, Newborn Baby Registry Must Haves, Baby Shower Gift, White
Pearhead
9.0GET ON AMAZON
6Pearhead First 5 Years Chevron Baby Memory Book with Clean-Touch Baby Safe Ink Pad to Make BabyPearhead First 5 Years Chevron Baby Memory Book with Clean-Touch Baby Safe Ink Pad to Make Baby’s Hand or Footprint Included, Gray
Pearhead
8.7GET ON AMAZON
7Malden International Designs Baby Memories Baby Memoto Shadowbox Picture Frame, 4x6, WhiteMalden International Designs Baby Memories Baby Memoto Shadowbox Picture Frame, 4×6, White
Malden International Designs
8.4GET ON AMAZON
8C.R. Gibson Keepsake Chest, All BoyC.R. Gibson Keepsake Chest, All Boy
C.R. Gibson
8.0GET ON AMAZON
9DEMDACO First Tooth and Curl Pink Ceramic Stoneware ChildrenDEMDACO First Tooth and Curl Pink Ceramic Stoneware Children’s Stackable Keepsake Box
Demdaco Baby
7.8GET ON AMAZON
10Baby Handprint Kit |NO Mold| Baby Picture Frame, Baby Footprint kit, Perfect for Baby Boy Gifts,Top Baby Girl Gifts, Baby Shower Gifts, Newborn Baby Keepsake FramesBaby Handprint Kit |NO Mold| Baby Picture Frame, Baby Footprint kit, Perfect for Baby Boy Gifts,Top Baby Girl Gifts, Baby Shower Gifts, Newborn Baby Keepsake Frames
Little Hippo
7.6GET ON AMAZON